Microsoft's Dominance and Initial Reaction to the iPhone
In 2006, just one year before the iPhone was released, Microsoft dominated the smartphone market with its Windows Mobile platform. When Apple revealed the iPhone, many expected Microsoft to compete aggressively and protect its market position. However, what transpired was one of the most significant missteps in modern tech history.
When the iPhone was revealed, many were impressed by its new technologies, but there was also substantial scepticism. Even Microsoft’s then-CEO, Steve Ballmer, dismissed the iPhone's potential success. He ridiculed its lack of a physical keyboard and high price, believing that business customers would prefer devices like the Motorola Q phone, which was significantly cheaper and featured a keyboard. This initial denial was Microsoft's first big mistake. While it's easy to recognise in hindsight, at the time, not having a physical keyboard on a smartphone seemed impractical, and the iPhone's high price raised doubts about its affordability and market potential.
The Importance of User Experience and Apple's Strategy
However, Microsoft and other competitors like BlackBerry failed to consider the importance of convenience and user experience. Apple's focus on these aspects proved invaluable. Just as the graphical interface and mouse revolutionised personal computers in the 1980s, the iPhone's touchscreen interface and intuitive design set a new standard for smartphones. Microsoft, like IBM in the 1980s, was late recognising this shift.
When the iPhone was launched, Steve Jobs set a goal for Apple to capture 1% of the worldwide mobile phone market share by 2008, aiming to sell 10 million iPhones. Despite scepticism from Ballmer and others, Apple surpassed this goal. By the fourth quarter of 2007, the iPhone had captured 6.5% of the worldwide smartphone market and an impressive 28% of the U.S. market, overtaking both Palm and Microsoft.
Microsoft's Inadequate Response and the Rise of Android
Instead of responding with a strategy shift, Microsoft remained focused on its existing Windows Mobile platform, designed primarily for business customers. Meanwhile, in November 2007, Google introduced Android, a mobile operating system designed for touchscreen smartphones, recognising the industry's shift towards touch interfaces. As a result, by 2008, Apple introduced the iPhone 3G, which was more affordable and had broader international availability, and the first Android device, the HTC Dream, was released.
Microsoft's reluctance to embrace the touchscreen revolution and its continued focus on business users disadvantaged it. While Apple and Android devices gained traction, Windows Mobile devices looked increasingly outdated. By 2009, Windows Mobile's market share had begun to shrink, and Microsoft finally realised they needed to develop a new operating system to compete with iOS and Android.
The Launch of Windows Phone 7
In 2010, Microsoft released Windows Phone 7, replacing Windows Mobile 6.5. The new OS received positive reviews for its fresh interface and responsiveness, but it lacked key features important to business users and had a limited app ecosystem. Despite its initial promise, Windows Phone 7 failed to attract a significant user base, with most customers already choosing between iOS and Android.
The Nokia Partnership and Lumia Series
To address hardware limitations, Microsoft partnered with Nokia in 2011, aiming to create a competitive product quickly. The Nokia Lumia 800, released later that year, was well-received but unavailable in the U.S. market. The Lumia 900 followed, receiving praise but still suffering from a lack of compelling apps and carrier support.
Microsoft made a significant strategic mistake by shifting from Windows Phone 7 to Windows Phone 8. The change to a new operating system with a different kernel meant existing Windows Phone 7 devices could not be upgraded, forcing loyal customers to purchase new hardware. This decision was repeated when transitioning to Windows 10 Mobile, causing further fragmentation and eroding customer trust, ultimately leading to a decline in the user base.
Struggles with App Ecosystem and Market Share Decline
By 2013, Microsoft's smartphone market share had dwindled to 3%, and they made a final push by purchasing Nokia’s smartphone business for $7.2 billion. However, their subsequent devices, like the Lumia 950, failed to impress, suffering from poor design, a lack of apps, and an unfinished operating system. By 2016, Microsoft's market share had plummeted to just 0.4%.
The End of Microsoft's Smartphone Venture
Finally, in October 2017, Microsoft announced it would no longer sell or manufacture new Windows 10 Mobile devices, marking the end of its venture into the smartphone market. Reflecting on this failure, Steve Ballmer admitted that Microsoft would have had a stronger position in the phone market if it had integrated hardware and software sooner.
Conclusion: The Rise and Fall of Microsoft's Smartphone Ambitions
In summary, The Rise and Fall of Microsoft's Smartphone Ambitions in the smartphone market can be attributed to strategic missteps, slow response to industry shifts, and an inability to deliver a compelling user experience and app ecosystem. Their initial denial of the iPhone's potential, repeated fragmentation of their user base, and poor partnership execution ultimately led to their downfall as a phone company.
Comments